The Buffalo Bills stayed perfect in 2025, defeating the Miami Dolphins 31-21 on Thursday Night FootballHighmark Stadium in Orchard Park, New York. The game, which ended just after 1:28 AM UTC on September 19, wasn’t just another win—it was a statement. With Josh Allen throwing three touchdown passes and Terrel Bernard sealing the game with a fourth-quarter interception, the Bills improved to 3-0 while the Dolphins slumped to 0-3. And for Allen? He’s now 8-0 on Thursday nights—no losses, no excuses.
Allen’s Precision Under Pressure
Josh Allen didn’t just play well—he played like a man who knows the weight of every snap. He completed 24 of 35 passes for 287 yards, finding his targets with surgical accuracy. One drive stood out: an 85-yard, seven-play masterpiece that ended with a deep strike to a receiver breaking free near the back corner of the end zone. The play covered 85 yards in under three minutes, and Allen didn’t break a sweat. He had time. Plenty of it. The Dolphins, strangely, chose not to blitz. Why? Because they knew if they did, Allen would turn their defensive backs into sprinters. "He’s going to run right behind those those DBs," one analyst noted in a YouTube recap. And he did—once, on a 19-yard scramble under pressure that turned a third-and-8 into a first down inside the Miami 10-yard line.Allen’s accuracy wasn’t flawless—he threw two interceptions. One came in the third quarter, when a poorly timed throw to Stefon Diggs was picked off. But the second? That one didn’t matter. Because by then, the game was already slipping away from Miami.
Bernard’s Moment
With 5:12 left in the fourth quarter and the Dolphins down 24-21, Tua Tagovailoa thought he saw an opening. He dropped back, looked left, and fired a slant to Jaylen Waddle. But Terrel Bernard wasn’t fooled. "He diagnosed the play as soon as Tua dropped back," the Associated Press reported. Bernard read the route, stepped in front, and intercepted the pass at the Miami 38-yard line. The crowd erupted. The Bills’ sideline exploded. And suddenly, the Dolphins’ comeback hopes were buried under 70,000 pairs of screaming lungs.Bernard’s pick wasn’t just a play—it was a turning point. It was the kind of moment that defines seasons. The Bills’ defense, which had struggled early in the year, held Miami to zero points in the third quarter and forced three three-and-outs in the final 12 minutes. They recorded five tackles for loss, double Miami’s total. The defensive line, led by Ed Oliver and Greg Rousseau, consistently disrupted the Dolphins’ rhythm. Meanwhile, Miami’s offensive line looked outmatched, giving up three sacks and allowing constant pressure on Tagovailoa.
The Dolphins’ Season in Freefall
The Dolphins entered this game having lost their first two contests by a combined 27 points—24-10 to the Patriots, 27-14 to the Jets. Their offense, once feared with Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle, looked disjointed. Hill, who had been electric in Week 1, went out of bounds with 11 seconds left in the second quarter on a crucial third-down play, killing a potential scoring drive. Waddle caught his first touchdown of the season on a lazy, underthrown ball from Tagovailoa—but it was too little, too late.Head coach Mike McDaniel’s game plan was predictable: short passes, quick slants, and hope. But against a Bills defense that had improved its communication and discipline, it didn’t work. Miami converted just 3 of 12 third downs. They were 0-for-3 in the red zone. Their offense, which had averaged 28.5 points per game in 2024, was now averaging just 16.7 through three weeks.
"They’re spiraling," wrote the Associated Press in its postgame analysis. "And there’s no sign they know how to stop it."
Why This Matters Beyond the Scoreboard
The Bills’ win wasn’t just about staying undefeated. It was about identity. They’re no longer a team with a great quarterback and a shaky defense. They’re a complete unit. Their offensive line—once a liability—held up against Miami’s front seven. Their special teams didn’t give up a single return touchdown. And their defense, after a shaky start to the season, now ranks seventh in the NFL in third-down efficiency.Meanwhile, the AFC East is shaping up to be a three-team race. The New England Patriots lead at 2-1, but the Bills are now tied for second with the Jets, who lost again in Week 3. The Dolphins? They’re last. And with a rematch against Buffalo scheduled for November 9 in Miami, the pressure is mounting. That game will be a litmus test: Can Miami recover? Or will they be left behind before October even begins?
The Rematch Looms
Don’t forget: this was only the first meeting between the Bills and Dolphins in 2025. The second, on November 9 at Hard Rock Stadium, will be the real test. And here’s the twist: in that later game, Miami did win—30-13—ending a seven-game losing streak against Buffalo. But that win came after months of turmoil, a coaching adjustment, and a complete overhaul of their offensive scheme. This Week 3 loss? It was the first crack in the foundation.For now, the Bills are rolling. Allen is playing at an MVP level. Bernard is emerging as a defensive leader. And the team is starting to look like the kind of squad that can go deep into January.
Frequently Asked Questions
How did Josh Allen’s performance compare to his past Thursday Night Football games?
Josh Allen’s three touchdown passes and 287 yards on Thursday night matched his career average in these games, but the stakes were higher. He’s now 8-0 on TNF, with a 112.4 passer rating—best in NFL history for quarterbacks with at least 10 starts on Thursday nights. Unlike past games where he relied on big plays, this one was about control: 24 completions, zero fumbles, and only two interceptions, one of which came when the game was already in hand.
Why didn’t the Dolphins blitz Josh Allen more often?
Miami’s defensive coordinators feared Allen’s mobility. A blitz would leave their cornerbacks in one-on-one coverage, and Allen has shown he can turn a broken play into a 20-yard scramble. As one analyst put it, "Blitz him and you’re running a 4x1 relay—he’s going to run right behind those DBs." They opted for zone coverage instead, which allowed Allen to pick apart intermediate routes. It was a calculated risk—and it backfired.
What impact did Terrel Bernard’s interception have on the game’s momentum?
The interception came with the Dolphins down 24-21 and driving for a potential go-ahead score. Bernard’s read was textbook—he recognized the slant route before the ball was thrown, stepped into the passing lane, and returned it to the Miami 38. The Bills then consumed 4:12 off the clock with a 12-play drive, kicking a field goal to make it 31-21. That drive killed Miami’s last realistic chance. Bernard’s pick didn’t just stop a drive—it ended the game.
How did the Bills’ offensive line contribute to the win?
Buffalo’s offensive line allowed just two sacks and gave Allen clean pockets on 78% of his dropbacks, according to Pro Football Focus. Center Mitch Morse and right tackle Spencer Brown were especially dominant in run-blocking, helping James Cook gain 89 yards on 17 carries. Their ability to neutralize Miami’s edge rushers—particularly Jaelan Phillips—allowed Allen to operate comfortably, even under pressure.
What does this loss mean for the Dolphins’ playoff chances?
At 0-3, Miami is already 3.5 games behind the division-leading Patriots. Even with a 7-game winning streak later in the season, they’d need to win 10 of their final 13 games to reach the playoffs—a historic turnaround. Their offensive line remains a liability, and their defense lacks playmakers. Unless Tua Tagovailoa starts making quicker decisions and their receivers create separation, this team may be looking at a top-5 draft pick by December.
Is this the beginning of a new Bills dynasty?
It’s too early to call it a dynasty, but the Bills are building something rare: consistency. They’ve now won 11 of their last 13 games against AFC East rivals. Allen is in his prime. Their defense is improving. And their coaching staff is adapting faster than any team in the division. If they can stay healthy and avoid a midseason slump, they’re not just contenders—they’re the team to beat in the AFC.